The Disabled God Revisited
By
3.11.24 |
Symposium Introduction
Panelists
Daniel Rempel
Miriam Spies
Jules Martinez
Bruce McCormack
Linn Tonstad
Heike Peckruhn
Overview
Lisa D. Powell strengthens and amplifies the claim that God is disabled, made by Nancy Eiesland in her ground breaking book The Disabled God (1994). She offers an alternative understanding of the doctrine of God and the Trinity, resulting in a God who is not autonomous and utterly independent. According to this view, God’s triune identity is established in God’s decision for covenant, and thus creation is a requirement for the fulfillment of God’s nature – not only is the Son always anticipating full embodiment and human nature, but more specifically is eternally anticipating an impaired body. Powell argues that God is not only interdependent within the immanent Trinity, but God experiences real dependency, risk and vulnerability from God’s “original” self-determination.
Powell revisits Eiesland’s claim about Christ’s resurrected body and her conclusions about eschatological embodiment, arguing that it is the able-body that does not persist eschatologically, but all humanity journeys toward ever more transparency, vulnerability and interdependency as the Body of Christ.
Reviews and Endorsements
“Nancy Eiesland’s Disabled God has shaped several generations of disability theologians, despite leaving some important theological questions unasked. Gathering together various criticisms in an extremely helpful way, Lisa D. Powell constructively and sympathetically extends Eisland’s liberation theology, and shows why the doctrine of God remains generative for a liberative theology today.” ―Brian Brock, University of Aberdeen, UK
“Do not let yourself be fooled by the modest title claim! Powell’s magnificent book is much more than a mere “revisiting” of Eiesland’s landmark Disabled God. Masterfully combining crip theory, queer critique, and Barth’s doctrine of election, Powell offers nothing short of a theological ontology of God as disabled, while at the same time pulling the rug out of disability as a human identity category. Finding the triune God constituted in the eternal election of the (impaired body of the) Son, she reclaims receptivity for a kenotic Christology from its feminist critics, develops the ensuing covenantal solidarity with creation, and develops an eschatological vision of deepening mutual interdependence rather than the retention of abled/disabled individuality. The result is a doctrinally sound, critically sourced, and constructively liberationist Christology that will have repercussions across a variety of fields in the years to come.” ―Hanna Reichel, Princeton Theological Seminary, USA
“If Barth’s Romans commentary was said to have dropped like a bomb on the playground of theologians, then Powell’s The Disabled God Revisited picks up the pieces left by Nancy Eiesland’s The Disability God deploying the Barthian shards. Barth studies gets reconfigured and extended, disability theology is fortified, and our understanding of God and ourselves is transformed in the process.” ―Amos Yong, Fuller Seminary, USA
“The Disabled God Revisited is a creative and timely intervention into debates about the Trinity, Christology, theological anthropology, and liberation. Skillfully gathering insights from cutting-edge studies of Karl Barth, theologies of disability, and feminist and queer thinkers, while also advancing a powerful constructive perspective of her own, Powell’s book will repay close study and inspire valuable conversations.” ―Paul Dafydd Jones, University of Virginia, USA
